• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Schools
  • Government/Politics
  • Food/Restaurant
  • Arts/Entertainment/Media
  • History
  • Health and Fitness
  • Sports
  • Kobe At Lower Merion
  • 21st Century On The Main Line

This Is Lower Merion And Narberth

Serving the Main Line Community

  • Ardmore
  • Bala Cynwyd
  • Belmont Hills
  • Bryn Mawr
  • Gladwyne
  • Haverford
  • Merion
  • Narberth
  • Penn Valley
  • Penn Wynne
  • Rosemont
  • Villanova
  • Wynnewood

Neighbors Are Underwhelmed With Main Line Health’s ‘City Of St. Charles’ Proposal

by Gerry February 14, 2024

You comment on this at the end of the article.

St Charles Plan 1

A filled-to-capacity crowd at Merion Tribute House on Tuesday night (February 13) listened to representatives from Main Line Health (MLH) make a pitch for what they are calling a “Wellness Village,” to be built on the former property of St. Charles Seminary. Members of Merion, Short Ridge, and Indian Creek Civic Associations, as well as a group called Seminary Neighbors, heard the presentation and were almost unanimously, enthusiastically opposed to the plan in its current form.

 

St Charles 2

The proposal that MLH presented includes:

  • A 400,000-square-foot outpatient facility (which is 1.5 times the size of all of Penn At Radnor
  • A mix of independent, assisted living, and memory care units.
  • A boutique hotel
  • Condominiums, townhouses and rental units
  • 5 miles of walk/bike trails
  • A shopping center with 20,000 square feet of retail

 

St Charles 3

There was a consensus among the residents that the MLH plan is a massive, for-profit development wrapped in the veneer of a healthcare facility. However, according to MLH, limiting the project to just the senior living and outpatient facilities would not be economically viable.

 

St Charles 4

One resident pointed out that what MLH wants to build at St. Charles will be comparable in size and density to the entire borough of Narberth. None of the spokespersons from the hospital group contradicted her claim.

When asked why more of the new facilities couldn’t be built on Lankenau’s existing property, the residents were told that was impossible because the hospital had already agreed with neighbors on that side of Lancaster Avenue, to leave the open space as it exists today.

MLH has submitted a request to Lower Merion Township to pass an ordinance that would create a new Zoning Class,  a “Wellness Village.” Without the passage of such an ordinance it will be virtually impossible for MLH to build anything close to what they are proposing at St. Charles.

Disclosure

The author’s home is adjacent to the former seminary.

Filed Under: Community Tagged With: St. Charles Seminary

Primary Sidebar

Sports

Family Learning To Luge

Want to Try Luge? From Lower Merion, It Starts With a Drive to Lake Placid

I was watching the Luge on NBC over the weekend. I thought it was boring, especially when juxtaposed against the more dramatic events, like curling.  The color commentator kept explaining how each “slider” was doing something slightly better or worse than the others, but to my untrained eye, they all looked the same: feet first, […]

Arts and Entertainment

These Garments Have Been Politically Maligned

Most non-Arabs who wear the keffiyeh do not intend it to be Anti-Semitic in any way. They wear it as an expression of sympathy for Palestinian civilians, support for human rights, concern about war, or identification with a broader cause of national identity and self-determination. In their minds, it is directed toward Palestinians, not against […]

What Does My Fountain Pen Have In Common With The Former Lord & Taylor In Bala Cynwyd?

Both come out of the work of Raymond Loewy and his design firm. Raymond Loewy (1893–1986) helped define what modern America looked like in the mid-20th century. Through his design firm, he worked across an unusually wide range of industries—transportation, consumer products, branding, and architecture—often simultaneously. No one in history is more closely associated with […]

January 16-18: The Philly Pen Show — A Delightfully Analog Experience

f you’re looking for a break from screens, alerts, and endless scrolling, the Philly Pen Show might be the cure—at least temporarily. It’s an unapologetically analog event: pens, paper, ink, and the people who still care deeply about them. Whether you’re a serious collector, someone who misses the feel of writing by hand, or just […]

More Posts from this Category

© 2019–2026